Project Guidelines
Projects are to be neatly written or typed (word processor). Charts, tables and graphs are to be neatly drawn using a straightedge (ruler) and appropriately labeled. Use graph paper when appropriate.
Show your work, answers alone will not be accepted. Papers torn from booklets and notebooks will not be accepted or graded. Projects with words or numbers crossed out will be rejected. Be sure to complete all the requirements of a project and answer all the questions. Incomplete projects will also be rejected.
Do not use pencils on the projects. Work done in pencil is not always transmitted by the fax machine. Please number and sign all pages faxed.
Send me an e-mail when faxing your projects. The results of your projects are sent as replies to your e-mail. There may be a delay between your sending a project and getting the results. I do not have a fax machine. The projects are sent by interoffice mail to my office and sometimes there are delays.
Project: Space Shuttle
Objective: Calculate probabilities to validate statements made in the video concerning the increased safety in the space shuttle design.
|
|
When the space shuttle Challenger exploded shortly
after
lift off, it was the responsibility of the investigation team to find the
cause of this tragedy. Their findings assigned the cause of the
explosion to the "O-rings" whose function was to contain the
rocket fuel
within the fuel cells.
When the rocket fuel leaked outside the fuel cell, it was ignited by the exhaust and the subsequent explosion followed. The space shuttle had two sets of O-rings. They were assumed to act independently. However, further study proved them to be dependent. Before the next space shuttle was launched, a third set of O-rings was installed. This new O-ring is truly independent of the other two. |
There were two statements made during the analysis of the space shuttle disaster that can be proved using statistics.
Statement #1: "When the space shuttle was launched, the crew had the same chances of surviving as if they were playing Russian Roulette using a gun having 8 chambers and 1 bullet."
Compare Russian Roulette
to the launch of the space shuttle.
Russian Roulette involves putting one bullet into a gun having 8
chambers, spinning the chambers, putting the gun to your head and pulling the trigger.
A. Calculate for Russian Roulette:
1. P(Surviving Russian Roulette)
2. P(Fatal accident playing Russian Roulette)
B. Launching of the
Space Shuttle
The O-ring (gasket) keeping the fuel gases from escaping is
held in place by 6 field joints.
The P(A single field joint functioning) = 0.977.
The 6 field joints act independently of
each other and all six field joints must function
properly to prevent an explosion on lift-off.
Calculate:
1. P(O-ring functioning)
which means a safe lift-off.
2. P(O-ring malfunctioning) which means an explosion on lift-off.
C. Compare the probabilities calculated in problems A and B.
D. Is statement #1 true or false?
Statement #2: "When the space shuttle was redesigned, it had an additional O-ring installed that was truly independent of the other two O-rings. This new O-ring increased the probability of the O-rings functioning successfully."
A. Using
the same O-ring probabilities from
the previous problem, fill in the probability
distribution table for the O-rings.
The initial set of two rings are dependent and act
as one
O-ring (when one O-ring moved, so did the other O-ring.)
The newly installed
third O-ring is truly independent
of the other O-rings. Treat
the third O-ring as a
second O-ring.
| Event | Probability |
| First set of O-rings function and second O-ring functions | |
| First set of O-rings malfunction and second O-ring functions | |
| First set of O-rings function and second O-ring malfunctions | |
| First set of O-rings malfunction and second O-ring malfunctions |
B. Let x
represent the number of O-ring malfunctions. Use the probabilities from
the above
table to fill in the
probability distribution table.
| x | P(x) |
| 0 | |
| 1 | |
| 2 |
C. Use the
probability distribution table above to find:
1. P(Explosion on lift-off)
2. P(Safe lift-off)
D. Compare the probabilities for a Safe Lift-Off from Statements 1 and 2.
E. Is statement #2 true or false?
Click on the hand
to view the solution.